Skip to content
2 Highland Avenue, Otisville, photo 1
View all 25 photos
2 Highland Avenue, photo 2
2 Highland Avenue, photo 3
2 Highland Avenue, photo 4
2 Highland Avenue, photo 5
2 Highland Avenue, photo 6
2 Highland Avenue, photo 7
2 Highland Avenue, photo 8
2 Highland Avenue, photo 9
2 Highland Avenue, photo 10
2 Highland Avenue, photo 11
2 Highland Avenue, photo 12
2 Highland Avenue, photo 13
2 Highland Avenue, photo 14
2 Highland Avenue, photo 15
2 Highland Avenue, photo 16
2 Highland Avenue, photo 17
2 Highland Avenue, photo 18
2 Highland Avenue, photo 19
2 Highland Avenue, photo 20
2 Highland Avenue, photo 21
2 Highland Avenue, photo 22
2 Highland Avenue, photo 23
2 Highland Avenue, photo 24
2 Highland Avenue, photo 25

2 Highland Avenue

Otisville, NY 10963 · Orange County

Beds
4
Baths
2
Sqft
2,560
Status
Active
On site
61 days

Know your budget before you tour. Get pre-qualified

About this home

Discover the space, character, and potential this 1880 home has to offer in the heart of Otisville. With approximately 2,560 square feet, this 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence provides a spacious layout filled with opportunities to make it your own. The inviting living room features a fireplace, while multiple additional rooms offer flexibility for a home office, hobby space, playroom, or additional living areas. A generously sized primary bedroom provides a comfortable retreat, and hardwood floors add warmth and timeless appeal throughout portions of the home. The kitchen is conveniently located on the lower level, creating a unique layout with plenty of storage and workspace. Outside, enjoy a level backyard with a deck, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Situated on a 7,085-square-foot lot in the Minisink Valley School District and within walking distance to restaurants and parks, this property is an excellent opportunity for buyers looking to restore and personalize a home with historic character and abundant living space.

Listed with eXp Realty · Kewin Garabito · Source: OneKey MLS

One Key MLS

Information provided by One Key MLS, and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate. Data last updated: Sep 17, 2026, 3:09 PM ET. ©2026 One Key MLS.

Estimate Your Monthly Payment

Estimate your mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, and Private Mortgage Insurance.

$2,110.13Total / mo

Estimated Monthly Payment

Principal & interest
$1,477.72 (70.0%)
Taxes
$432.42 (20.5%)
Insurance
$200.00 (9.5%)

Representative rates

Representative rates only, indicative for comparison. Edit the interest rate for your own quote; your lender’s numbers vary with credit, points, and insurance.

Never miss a property

Be the first to know when a Orange County home hits the market.

Save this search

Market Insights

The market around Otisville, NY

Current Listings

New in the last 30 days

4

Sep 2026

Average Price

Active listings

$477,275

Sep 2026

Average Days on Market

Active listings

197 days

Sep 2026

Computed from 24 active OneKey MLS listings in Otisville, NY.

Similar homes in Orange County

See all 513
291 1st Street, Newburgh, NY
Photo 1 of 2
Coming SoonNew

$279,999

3 Bed • 2 Bath • 1,248 Sq. Ft.

291 1st Street

Newburgh, NY 12550

Listed with Howard Hanna Rand Realty

143 Deer Court Drive, Middletown, NY
Photo 1 of 26
Coming SoonNew

$299,000

2 Bed • 2 Bath • 1,291 Sq. Ft.

143 Deer Court Drive

Middletown, NY 10940

Listed with Howard Hanna Rand Realty

49 Matthews Lane, Washingtonville, NY
Photo 1 of 28
Coming SoonNew

$355,000

2 Bed • 2.5 Bath • 1,150 Sq. Ft.

49 Matthews Lane

Washingtonville, NY 10992

Listed with RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group