$1,100,000
4 Bed • 2.5 Bath • 2,639 Sq. Ft.4 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,639 sqft
71 Peale Place
Montgomery, NY 12549
Listed with Keller Williams Realty
$1,050,000
Est. $7,467/moNew Windsor, NY 12553 · Orange County
Know your budget before you tour. Get pre-qualified
An 1833 Georgian Colonial, Beautifully Preserved and Fully Reimagined COMING SOON! Showings begin 10/22/26. Built in 1833 and set on nearly two acres of terraced, tree-lined grounds, this 4,500-square-foot Georgian colonial is a rare marriage of historic character and flawless modern living. Meticulously maintained and thoughtfully updated, it offers five bedrooms across three levels without sacrificing a single bit of its original charm. Step through the front door and the home opens in one sweeping line of sight, straight through to sliding doors and the bluestone patio beyond. Original hardwood floors run throughout most of the home, grounding every room in its history. At the heart of the home, the sunlit eat-in kitchen is a true chef’s space, featuring an 8-burner Wolf range, 48" Sub-Zero refrigerator, double oven, oversized island, silestone countertops, and a dedicated beverage station. It flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, where a fireplace sets an elegant tone, and into the living room with its handsome built-ins. A first-floor office with a private entrance, fireplace, and full bath is ideal for working from home or hosting guests in total privacy. Finishing off the first floor is the laundry area and a powder room. Upstairs, the second floor offers three bedrooms and two full baths, featuring generous closets and abundant storage. The primary suite includes an ensuite bath and updated closets. The third bedroom has its own fireplace and direct access to the hall bathroom. The recently renovated third floor adds two more bedrooms and a newly updated bath, with additional closet and storage space. The grounds are as memorable as the house. Perennial gardens, specimen trees, and natural stone walls define the property, all enclosed by a stockade fence for privacy. The lawn was terraced in the 1940s to host a wedding reception, and those graceful tiers remain today, creating distinct outdoor rooms for entertaining. In the back corner, a heated saltwater in-ground pool completes the setting. Practical luxuries abound: a three-car garage (two bays heated and currently used as a home gym), a full basement with a workbench and new Bilco doors, a whole-house generator, 200-amp electric service, a 300-foot well with a water softener, a Vermont slate roof, and a boiler just ten years old. Easy access to commuter train to the city, located in the Cornwall School District. A one-of-a-kind offering that delivers history, privacy, and every modern comfort. A must-see! Interior photos to be added soon.
As reported by the listing office; verify enrollment with the district.
Listed with Howard Hanna Rand Realty · Deidre McGinty · Source: OneKey MLS
Information provided by One Key MLS, and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate. Data last updated: Oct 15, 2026, 10:08 AM ET. ©2026 One Key MLS.
Estimate your mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, and private mortgage insurance.
Estimated monthly payment
Representative rates
Representative rates only, indicative for comparison. Edit the interest rate for your own quote; your lender’s numbers vary with credit, points, and insurance.
Be the first to know when an Orange County home hits the market.
Market insights
Current listings
New in the last 30 days
38
Oct 2026
Average price
Active listings
$609,402
Oct 2026
Average days on market
Active listings
130 days
Oct 2026
Computed from 147 active OneKey MLS listings in New Windsor, NY.
$1,100,000
4 Bed • 2.5 Bath • 2,639 Sq. Ft.4 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,639 sqft
71 Peale Place
Montgomery, NY 12549
Listed with Keller Williams Realty
$795,000
4 Bed • 3 Bath • 3,160 Sq. Ft.4 bd · 3 ba · 3,160 sqft
1964 State Route 32
New Windsor, NY 12553
Listed with RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group
$775,000
4 Bed • 3 Bath • 3,212 Sq. Ft.4 bd · 3 ba · 3,212 sqft
1150 E Mombasha Road
Monroe, NY 10950
Listed with RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group