$1,585,000
6 Bed • 3.5 Bath • 5,221 Sq. Ft.
238 Wrentham Street
Kingston, NY 12401
Listed with Compass Greater NY, LLC
$1,496,000
Est. $10,044/moNew Paltz, NY 12561 · Ulster County
Know your budget before you tour. Get pre-qualified
There are homes you admire, and then there are homes you admire and carry them with you for years...the kind you pass countless times and quietly wonder about. Who lived there? What the lives looked like within those walls? What celebrations filled the rooms? What stories unfolded beside the fireplaces on winter evenings? Which generation planted the trees, walked the fields, gathered around the long kitchen table, or watched the seasons roll across the ridge from the same windows that remain today? 652 Albany Post Road is just that kind of home. Sited on 39 remarkable acres, beneath the Shawangunk Ridge, this c.1800 brick and stone Colonial, with its earlier stone wing, stands as one of Gardiner's most enduring historic presences. Timeless and deeply rooted in place, the home feels less like a property and more like a living piece of Hudson Valley history. Inside, centuries of craftsmanship remain beautifully intact. Wide plank floors worn smooth with time, hand-hewn beams, original millwork, deep-set windows, Dutch doors, built-ins, and multiple fireplaces create interiors rich with warmth, texture, and memories. The oldest stone portion of the home centers around an extraordinary hearth kitchen where exposed masonry, dark timber beams, and the original fireplace evoke another era entirely, a room that feels made for lingering conversations, candlelight, and generations gathered together. The elegant brick and stone Colonial section offers gracious proportions and beautifully scaled rooms filled with soft natural light. Arched openings, antique mantels, and expansive living spaces create an atmosphere which feels both stately and deeply personal. A first-floor bedroom and full bath provide flexibility for guests or even potential single-level living. The upstairs bedrooms feel peaceful, private, and suspended back in time. Outside, the landscape unfolds into rolling lawns, meadows, mature trees, and some wooded acreage. The setting is quintessential Gardiner: pastoral, protected, and impossibly serene. What makes this property extraordinary is not perfection or trend-driven renovation. It is authenticity and history. It gives you the feeling that it has been lived in, loved deeply, and carefully carried forward for more than two centuries. A rare opportunity here to become the next steward of one of the Hudson Valley's truly unforgettable, iconic homes.
As reported by the listing office; verify enrollment with the district.
Listed with Compass Greater NY, LLC · Donna Brooks · Source: OneKey MLS
Information provided by One Key MLS, and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate. Data last updated: Sep 17, 2026, 4:09 PM ET. ©2026 One Key MLS.
Estimate your mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, and Private Mortgage Insurance.
Estimated Monthly Payment
Representative rates
Representative rates only, indicative for comparison. Edit the interest rate for your own quote; your lender’s numbers vary with credit, points, and insurance.
Be the first to know when a Ulster County home hits the market.
Market Insights
Current Listings
New in the last 30 days
14
Sep 2026
Average Price
Active listings
$792,974
Sep 2026
Average Days on Market
Active listings
138 days
Sep 2026
Computed from 72 active OneKey MLS listings in New Paltz, NY.
$1,585,000
6 Bed • 3.5 Bath • 5,221 Sq. Ft.
238 Wrentham Street
Kingston, NY 12401
Listed with Compass Greater NY, LLC
$1,200,000
4 Bed • 2.5 Bath • 2,112 Sq. Ft.
382 Band Camp Road
Saugerties, NY 12477
Listed with Coldwell Banker Village Green
$1,200,000
3 Bed • 2.5 Bath • 2,905 Sq. Ft.
134 Costa Road
Highland, NY 12528
Listed with Howard Hanna Rand Realty