Skip to content
37 Rumsey Road, Greenwood Lake, photo 1
View all 48 photos
37 Rumsey Road, photo 2
37 Rumsey Road, photo 3
37 Rumsey Road, photo 4
37 Rumsey Road, photo 5
37 Rumsey Road, photo 6
37 Rumsey Road, photo 7
37 Rumsey Road, photo 8
37 Rumsey Road, photo 9
37 Rumsey Road, photo 10
37 Rumsey Road, photo 11
37 Rumsey Road, photo 12
37 Rumsey Road, photo 13
37 Rumsey Road, photo 14
37 Rumsey Road, photo 15
37 Rumsey Road, photo 16
37 Rumsey Road, photo 17
37 Rumsey Road, photo 18
37 Rumsey Road, photo 19
37 Rumsey Road, photo 20
37 Rumsey Road, photo 21
37 Rumsey Road, photo 22
37 Rumsey Road, photo 23
37 Rumsey Road, photo 24
37 Rumsey Road, photo 25
37 Rumsey Road, photo 26
37 Rumsey Road, photo 27
37 Rumsey Road, photo 28
37 Rumsey Road, photo 29
37 Rumsey Road, photo 30
37 Rumsey Road, photo 31
37 Rumsey Road, photo 32
37 Rumsey Road, photo 33
37 Rumsey Road, photo 34
37 Rumsey Road, photo 35
37 Rumsey Road, photo 36
37 Rumsey Road, photo 37
37 Rumsey Road, photo 38
37 Rumsey Road, photo 39
37 Rumsey Road, photo 40
37 Rumsey Road, photo 41
37 Rumsey Road, photo 42
37 Rumsey Road, photo 43
37 Rumsey Road, photo 44
37 Rumsey Road, photo 45
37 Rumsey Road, photo 46
37 Rumsey Road, photo 47
37 Rumsey Road, photo 48

37 Rumsey Road

Greenwood Lake, NY 10925 · Orange County

Beds
2
Baths
2.5
Sqft
1,844
Status
Active
On site
70 days

Know your budget before you tour. Get pre-qualified

About this home

Welcome to 37 Rumsey Road, a one-of-a-kind custom home nestled on .89 private acres in the heart of Greenwood Lake. This legal 2-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers exceptional space, character, and endless possibilities. Step inside to discover soaring ceilings, an impressive wall of windows that fills the home with natural light, and a sunken dining area perfect for entertaining. The spacious main level primary bedroom features two closets and a en suite bath for added comfort and convenience. Upstairs, you’ll find the second bedroom along with two additional finished rooms currently used as a gym and a home office, plus a charming loft area overlooking the living area that’s perfect for a reading nook or creative space. The walkout lower level expands the homes versatility with a finished recreation room, a half bath, and an oversized garage with room for up to three vehicles, storage, or hobbies. Outside, enjoy your own private retreat featuring a large pool, expansive yard, and nearly an acre of property offering plenty of room to relax, entertain, or simply enjoy the peaceful surroundings. A rare opportunity to own a distinctive home with flexible living space, abundant natural light, and an unbeatable location just minutes from the lake, shops, restaurants, and everything Greenwood Lake has to offer.

Listed with Keller Williams Realty · Tracy McNamara · Source: OneKey MLS

One Key MLS

Information provided by One Key MLS, and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate. Data last updated: Sep 17, 2026, 4:09 PM ET. ©2026 One Key MLS.

Estimate Your Monthly Payment

Estimate your mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, and Private Mortgage Insurance.

$3,896.18Total / mo

Estimated Monthly Payment

Principal & interest
$2,950.52 (75.7%)
Taxes
$745.67 (19.1%)
Insurance
$200.00 (5.1%)

Representative rates

Representative rates only, indicative for comparison. Edit the interest rate for your own quote; your lender’s numbers vary with credit, points, and insurance.

Never miss a property

Be the first to know when a Orange County home hits the market.

Save this search

Market Insights

The market around Greenwood Lake, NY

Current Listings

New in the last 30 days

7

Sep 2026

Average Price

Active listings

$693,372

Sep 2026

Average Days on Market

Active listings

118 days

Sep 2026

Computed from 53 active OneKey MLS listings in Greenwood Lake, NY.

Similar homes in Orange County

See all 1,083
110-112 S Jacqueline Street, New Windsor, NY
Photo 1 of 6
Coming SoonNew

$619,900

5 Bed • 2 Bath

110-112 S Jacqueline Street

New Windsor, NY 12553

Listed with RE/MAX Benchmark Realty Group

7 Abbey Road, Warwick, NY
Photo 1 of 3
Coming SoonNew

$629,900

3 Bed • 2 Bath • 1,440 Sq. Ft.

7 Abbey Road

Warwick, NY 10990

Listed with Howard Hanna Rand Realty

104 Ayers Court, Montgomery, NY
Photo 1 of 43
Coming SoonNew

$529,000

3 Bed • 3 Bath • 2,504 Sq. Ft.

104 Ayers Court

Montgomery, NY 12549

Listed with KW Hudson Valley United