$1,375,000
4 Bed • 4.5 Bath • 3,222 Sq. Ft.4 bd · 4.5 ba · 3,222 sqft
134 Fostertown Road
Newburgh, NY 12550
Listed with Keller Williams Realty
$1,650,000
Est. $9,104/moCuddebackville, NY 12729 · Orange County
Know your budget before you tour. Get pre-qualified
Custom-Built Residence and Renovated Four-Unit Commercial Building Across from the Lower Bashakill Preserve This mixed-use property pairs a 3,500 sq ft custom Schoonmaker residence built in 1993 with a fully renovated 6,000 sq ft commercial building, originally an 1860s dairy barn. Located directly across from the 138-acre Lower Bashakill Preserve, the property offers excellent road visibility, ample parking, and convenient access to major routes, hiking trails, rivers, wineries, and regional attractions. Residence | 3,500 sq ft The 10-room home features a grand foyer and 9-foot ceilings. The first-floor 16’ × 22’ living room has a triple sliding door that opens to a covered walkway and evergreen garden. The 14’ × 16’ dining room connects to a butler’s pantry with a refrigerator, cabinetry, and access to an 880 sq ft deck. The 15’ × 17’ kitchen features deep tile countertops, oak cabinetry, and a pantry. A 12’ × 20’ office, a full marble-and-tile bath, a laundry room, and a side entry complete the first floor. Upstairs, the 14’ × 18’ primary bedroom has a dormer sitting area and walk-in closet. The second floor also includes two additional bedrooms, a media and game room, and an arts and crafts room. Both activity rooms have walk-in storage. Commercial Building | 6,000 sq ft The renovated barn houses a hair salon and three additional retail stores, each with separate utilities. The former watchman’s residence on the second floor offers approximately 1,500 sq ft, including a loft with a vaulted ceiling, with potential for office use or additional workspace, subject to applicable approvals. The property offers approximately 400 feet of road frontage and a 9,500 sq ft tree-lined parking area with two points of access. Additional features include two freestanding buildings measuring 12’ × 16’ and 10’ × 50’, an attached garden and storage room, a 40’ × 10’ partially enclosed rear awning, and updated roofing.
As reported by the listing office; verify enrollment with the district.
Listed with Real Estate Circuit Inc · Michelle P Gruberger · Source: OneKey MLS
Information provided by One Key MLS, and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed accurate. Data last updated: Nov 14, 2026, 7:07 PM ET. ©2026 One Key MLS.
Estimate your mortgage payment, including the principal and interest, taxes, insurance, HOA, and private mortgage insurance.
Estimated monthly payment
Representative rates
Representative rates only, indicative for comparison. Edit the interest rate for your own quote; your lender’s numbers vary with credit, points, and insurance.
Be the first to know when an Orange County home hits the market.
Market insights
Current listings
New in the last 30 days
2
Nov 2026
Average price
Active listings
$503,563
Nov 2026
Average days on market
Active listings
117 days
Nov 2026
Computed from 11 active OneKey MLS listings in Cuddebackville, NY.
$1,375,000
4 Bed • 4.5 Bath • 3,222 Sq. Ft.4 bd · 4.5 ba · 3,222 sqft
134 Fostertown Road
Newburgh, NY 12550
Listed with Keller Williams Realty
$1,249,999
4 Bed • 3 Bath • 4,538 Sq. Ft.4 bd · 3 ba · 4,538 sqft
172 Stony Ford Road
Middletown, NY 10916
Listed with Keller Williams Realty
$1,499,999
3 Bed • 2 Bath • 3,450 Sq. Ft.3 bd · 2 ba · 3,450 sqft
283 Prospect Road
Monroe, NY 10950
Listed with Mount Realty